Honestly not funny, the writing needs extreme work. I saw your post in the forums, and while it is unfair to rate this without reviewing it, I think the score of 3 stars is plenty fair. I understand you spent a couple of months working on this, but it just wasn't impressive.
Well, it's impressive if you compare it to my older works. It might not be impressive if compared to something by the more experienced animators. I was never really trying to be funny with this, but I found some humor in it so I labeled it as comedy. I honestly don't care about score, it just seems like nowadays, people don't watch anything unless it has a decent score, and all an artist wants is for people to see their stuff. Thanks for the feedback, even if I don't fully agree with it, it is helpful and shows that I still need to improve, and Improve I will.
It kinda sucks to know that we'd have a straight 5 stars from everyone if not for the guys who comment "this belongs in the audio portal" with 0 stars and no real fair reasoning behind that. I don't understand why they don't take time out of their day to comment on the submissions that REALLY broke the rules, but whatever. That's just my opinion.
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.